I realize I'm a day late, but as an excuse I have work. Midshifts leave little time for much else! But, here goes:
First, I have to explain that when the Howler was born, they handed me this little thing...and she terrified me. She looked at me, and I was more afraid of her than I've ever been before in my life. It felt like a primal fear--like I would never be able to survive this. That feeling has mellowed, some, and she's grown into a spectacularly herself kind of person. But even as an infant, she had something about her that said, "Sit up. Take notice: I'm HERE." She screamed for several hours a day, and as she grew and became self-motorvating, she screamed less. I honestly believe, 6.5 years later, that much of the screaming was frustrating at not being able to do the things she wanted to do (we still experience the screamfest whenever she is monumentally frustrated at not being "big enough" to actually DO things.)
And that's just the backstory of our relationship. I worry that I have been given this awesomely terrifying responsibility: How do I help her be who she is, yet balance it with socially and culturally acceptable skills? What I mean is, how do I protect the "who she really is" against the obvious need to be social, have friends, have a place (which, I'm sure, she'll need to be creating for herself) in the world?
I first realized this was what I needed to do when she was just-turned-5 years old. And I learned then that my biggest obstacle would be her father.
She was attending a Christian preschool--a good school, and a good fit for her--and it was the day of her 5-year checkup (including the pre-Kindergarten shots.) I had laid out her clothes for preschool the night before, and she was more than able to get herself dressed. She goes to school, and we head to McDonald's a treat for lunch (I knew those shots were coming.)
At McDonald's, she has to use the bathroom, and of course, I have to go with her. I discover to my shock that she had *failed* to put on the panties I put out for her. She had failed to put on panties at all.
I inform her that we will need to go home and put some one before we go the doctor's. She tells me, "No fanks, Mommy."
"Yes, fanks, Howler."
"No, really. I'm fine fanks."
"No, really. We're going home; you're putting them on."
The conversation continues in this vein for the trip home and to the doc's. I explain that it's not acceptable to not wear panties when out-in-public. She wants to know how I know this (this line of questioning preceded the "are you lying?" line I got the following year.)
I explain that it's just the way it is, and once she no longer lives in my house, she can do as she pleases with--or without--underwear, but until then, she WILL wear panties when she leaves the house, or company comes over.
I'm smothering laughter this whole time.
After supper, when My Sweetie gets home, I tell him about my day--and this little adventure.
He IMMEDIATELY began saying things like, "NOT MY DAUGHTER" and "YOU, little girl, will be a LADY."
I literally dragged him from the room. He kept going. I don't even remember what exactly he said, because I was trying to keep from choking the life out of him.
Everything he was saying was the opposite of the things I am. I'm not a lady (but I could play one on TV.) I still get a rash when my mother says things like this to or about me. He not only misses the humor in it (especially the part about how it was pure chance she didn't wear a dress that day) and he likes the parts of me that are surprising, not-ladylike, and not usually socially acceptable--he revels in that side of me, usually.
And here he is, being a total spaz.
Finally, I get him to shut up enough to ask him, "And if this had been your SON who did this, what would your reaction be?"
"Honestly? I'd laugh, and not think much of it."
"Then that's what your reaction to this would be."
"But she needs to be..."
"OH NO BUT SHE DOESN'T! She does need to know that she is to wear underwear when she's in public, and when people are over, but YOU don't wear underwear all the time, and I don't wear underwear all the time, and SHE doesn't need to either."
He's still clinging to the whole "my daughter will be a lady" idiocy thing. Finally, I ask him if he thinks I'm unacceptable because I'm not a lady.
"No, you're fine."
"Then STOP being your father, and let her be. Help me teach her that who she is is okay, ladylike or not, and that there are rules to follow--like wearing underwear at certain times--too."
I thought that would settle it. I was wrong. Over the past almost two years, I've spent more time trying to buffer his "my daughter" idiocy than I care to admit. He's somehow got the idea that what's okay in his wife is not okay in his daughter. It makes me feel that he isn't admitting that he wishes I were someone else.
Over this past weekend, I'd finally had it. I know my family--especially my mother--is dysfunctional when it comes to what's "proper" and "right." He admits that his family can also be dysfunctional, but in a quieter way.
Don't get me wrong. His parents are decent, hard working people. I like them. I respect them. But it's not a secret that there are times when I bite my tongue for days on end when we visit. His sisters are kind, compassionate women. I like them. I respect them. But there are times when I want to scream because they all defer, sometimes to their detriment, to their father--the "man." They'll cry in secret because of something he's said. And I've heard the story over and over again about his one sister, who as a teen, "used a lot of body powder" as part of her beauty routine. Their father was, according to what I've been told, not understanding/tolerant of it to the point that EVERY. DAY. was filled with some hollering and many tears on her part. Whether she went overboard with the powder or not was not an issue for me--the fact that he was intolerant of her, to the point of making her cry, even if she was not using powder that day, is.
And I see the same thing in how My Sweetie reacts to and treats his daughter. He's a loving man, and he is a good father. He was overjoyed the Christmas he wanted to buy her some Hot Wheels cars and I encouraged him to get the bigger set, knowing how much they'd both enjoy it.
He was delighted the time he went to purchase the PowerWheels jeep for her, and I vetoed the pink Barbie jeep. (He brought home a John Deere tractor. I didn't even sigh or blink. She loves it.) He loves that she plays hard and doesn't worry about getting dirty, the only bugs she can't stand are spiders--in short, she's not prissy at all. She is girly enough to want long hair, and she likes dresses--in short, she's all girl--but she also doesn't put up with any one telling her that she can't do something/like something/be something just because she's a girl. The boys in the neighborhood and at school have come to respect it. And her Daddy revels in it.
But give him something culturally slanted against girls? It gets ugly at my house. This weekend, I asked him if he wanted HIS daughter to have a relationship with her father like HE had with his (they didn't get along for years, and even after he'd been sober for two years, his father was still beating that dead horse.) He said no. I asked then, if he wanted HIS daughter to have a relationship with HER father like his sisters have. He said no.
I think I got through, but the constant monitoring of his unspoken, unacknowledged, and unknowing "my daughter" idiocy is wearing. It's even more frustrating because he's seen the stress and frustration and anger I have when I'm treated "like a girl" at work--he's proud of the fact that I don't hide behind my gender, and that I am respected at work, not because of, but inspite of, my gender. (In other words, there's no qualifying "for a girl" that is part of who I am, at home, or at work.)
I'm still trying to get him to understand that how HE is with her NOW will be part of who she is in ten-twenty-thirty years. How afraid she is of her sexuality as an adult, how she responds to boys in her teens, how she has relationships as an adult are all built on the foundation of not just his relationship with me (and vice versa) but also his relationship--including his unspoken and unacknowledged belief in who she is as a person, as a girl, and as a woman.
I have seen my daughter's self-esteem enemy, and he lives in the house with us.
I'm participating in the
Self-Esteem Carnival at Lords of the Manor, go there for more information and interesting reads.